I cannot believe September 11, 2001, was twenty-five years ago.
One of the slogans of that period was “Never Forget.” What is sad is that a lot of us have. The phrase still gets said. The people it was supposed to name do not always travel with it.
![]() |
| @America on X |
What I notice first, a day after the anniversary, is not only the forgetting. It is that we still hear people say we deserved it.
Deserved it. As if the people who went to work at the World Trade Center or the Pentagon, or the passengers on those four flights, had billed the country for something and the bill came due on a Tuesday morning. That is a horrendous thing to say about the dead. It is also a way of changing the subject from what happened to a running argument about everything America has ever done.
The attack had a source, a method, and a target. Those are not mysteries. Treating the day as a receipt for prior sins is a way of not looking at the people who were at their desks.
I do not want to wade into the debate over whether Islam is compatible with Western civilization. I believe in freedom of religion. My instinct is to reject the claim that Islam is, as a whole, a violent faith, and to reject the claim that violent fundamentalism is simply “Middle Eastern culture.” Plenty of Americans who practice the faith live under the same secular law the rest of us do.
What I will not dismiss is the other sentence we keep hearing: that some neighborhoods have, in effect, adopted a different rulebook. Dearborn, Michigan, is the name that gets used. Last month it was not an abstraction. At an Aug. 18 city council meeting, moved to the Henry Ford Centennial Library after a “Christian Crusader March” drew a crowd and 22 arrests outside, Detroit pastor Lorenzo Sewell of 180 Church told the dais the city was no longer under American law. “We are up under Sharia law,” he said. “We will not have it anymore.” The clip ran for days. Sewell’s examples were the call to prayer, halal meat in schools, Arabic on storefronts, and what he called a two-tier response after activist Jake Lang was assaulted at an earlier protest. Fox noted he was not pointing to an ordinance. He was pointing to favoritism. Council members did not denounce Sharia when he asked them to.
Britannica and city officials say Dearborn is not under Sharia. Last week Rep. Keith Self of Texas filed a concurrent resolution denouncing it nationwide, citing a late-August remark by President Trump. The argument is loud because the stakes are not small. America has a Judeo-Christian history. Its laws are secular. Those two facts can sit together. They cannot sit with a parallel legal system that answers to a different source.
If any pocket of the country is running on a different set of rules, the answer is not a sermon about which faith is worse. The answer is the same one we already have on paper: one set of secular laws, and protection for people who practice all of them.
In 2001 we had a lot to be thankful for. We lived in a country that still offered liberty and opportunity to people willing to take it. Twenty-five years later the fight I see is less about the men who flew the planes and more about how little some of us still think that offer is worth.
Terrorism is not gone. It is also not the only thing that can hollow out a country. The quieter work is teaching people that the dead on those flights and in those buildings did not earn what they got, and that the system that let the rest of us keep living here is not an inheritance you get to spend down while calling it justice.
The enemy that morning had a face and a method. The one that lasts is harder to point at. It is the habit of treating the dead as a moral, and the country as something you apologize for instead of keep.

